Which keeper would you rather have and why?

Keeper 1:

Keeping: 94
Tackle: 23
Passing: 72
Shooting: 27
Speed: 87
Dribble: 95
Control: 86
Header: 90
Aggressiveness: 74

Keeper 2:
Keeping: 89
Tackle: 34
Passing: 83
Shooting: 32
Speed: 100
Dribble: 87
Control: 90
Header: 91
Aggressiveness: 6

Keeper 1, keeping and speed are key for me but 87 is more than acceptable.

Neither keeper would be good enough for a CL competing team.

What’s the average rating you expect of a CL competing team keeper?

According to game rules (60% Kpg, 40% Spe) Keeper 2 is better (93.4 vs. 91.2 weighted avg). Seems like a good enough keeper to me to get you through any championship (off course, a better GK is always better…)

Keeper 1 is better….
I use a 88 keeper and he cant make any saves.
My keeper have ZERO M.O.T.M, he is useless!

Team plays well, only the keeper is very bad.
When I lose, the opponent mostly have their keeper M.O.T.M or one of their players.
Even when I have a player M.O.T.M I still lose, normally this is not the case if you have a 93+ keeper.

Reason why I use a 88 keeper is because 6 seasons ago I had 6 YOUTH KEEPERS.
I guess I gambled wrong, since then I cant win anything haha
I must say, having 6 youth as a keeper shouldnt happen!!
The game just screwed my team and me for the past 6 seasons…

I agree, keeper 2 normally has very good match ratings but let’s in many goals.

Keeper 1 might not have a better rating but will keep more clean sheets.

I would choose keeper 2 in this case because there’s a big difference according to the rules.

I have a similar keeper Ontiveros and he is for sale. I sell him because I have an even better young keeper. I agree you won’t win CL with Ontiveros but he will give you titles. He is already 4 times M.O.M.T.

Gabriel Ontiveros
Keeping: 87
Tackle: 35
Passing: 80
Shooting: 25
Speed: 100
Dribble: 92
Control: 87
Header: 92
Aggressiveness: 38
Stamina: 100

I agree with Dirk, he is a Game Master :)

Keeper 1 has the better weighted average for keeping/speed and keeping/header, but keeper 2 has a much higher value. Not only that, the average rating of keeper 2 is much higher (while he plays away games and keeper 1 the home games).

I do wonder how important passing is for a keeper.